|
||||||||
|
No Cease Fire by Allan Topol, 2005
ARTICLE ORIGINALLY APPEARED AT
MILITARY.COM, August 03, 2006
Amid all of the noise and static on CNN about civilian casualties in Lebanon, lets not forget how this war started. After spending six years engaged in massive arming with sophisticated weapons being supplied by Syria and Lebanon, and digging fortresses and tunnels, Hezbollah felt strong enough to strike at Israel. They kidnapped two Israeli soldiers and killed several others. This type of naked aggression cannot be rewarded. Hezbollah cannot be permitted to achieve gains from such a flagrant terrorist attack on another nation. If they do, this will become the standard for the world. We will be face with hit and run attacks by Jihadists terrorists in many other countries throughout the world.
Also, lets not forget what occurred in 1983. Hezbollah suicide bombers blew up barracks of the United States and France, killing 300 troops. One more historical note. Notwithstanding Hezbollahs existence, Israel voluntarily withdrew form all of Lebanon in 2000. The UN Security Council confirmed that this Israeli withdrawal was complete according to international maps. Any claims to the contrary about Israeli possession of Shebaa Farms are inconsistent with international law.
It is unfortunate that there have been civilian casualties in Lebanon. It is also unfortunate that Israelis have died and been wounded in the rocket attacks, more than a hundred which have been fired in many given days. There is a fundamental difference in these two types of casualties. The Israelis have been making a concerted effort at minimizing civilian casualties while achieving their fundamental objectives. This has meant severing Hezbollah from its resupply in Syria. The task has been difficult because Hezbollah militants have deliberately taken cover in civilian areas.
On the other hand, there is no military objective to the Hezbollah rocket attacks. Their objective, firing randomly, often with warheads filled with ball bearings and nails, has been to inflict as much civilian suffering as possible on Israel.
As in every war, there is a shift in the tempo of the battle. According to todays news, the Israelis have stepped up their ground attacks in Lebanon, increasing the number of troops going into that country in an effort to hunt out and destroy the Hezbollah positions. This campaign has taken longer than the Israelis initially hoped, but the tide is now turning to their favor. This is why Hezbollah joined the chorus of Europeans in seeking an immediate cease fire.
There is only one rational way for this war to end. That is by having Israel destroy Hezbollah positions and then permitting an armed international force to move into the area separating Israel and Lebanon. The international force cannot be expected to police Hezbollah and to disarm them. Only the Israelis can do that. Once that occurs, the Europeans or Turks or whoever signs on, can take up their positions in the border area in the strip which Israel has cleared in Southern Lebanon.
Once that occurs, the rebuilding can begin in Lebanon. It is possible under this scenario that for the first time a real democratic Lebanon can emerge from the rubble of this Hezbollah commenced war. That can only happen, however, once Hezbollah is fully disarmed and has abandoned its military positions. They may continue to have a voice in the Lebanese government. That is a matter for Lebanons democracy to determine. However, they cannot exist as a separate military attacking a neighbor and instituting terrorist attacks as a separate army within a nation.
There is a great deal riding on this Israeli war. The Israelis are fighting not merely for themselves, but a proxy war on behalf of the United States against Iran, Hezbollahs supporter, and jihadist militants everywhere. The Israelis are also fighting on behalf of the Saudis, Egyptians and Western European governments who face the same risk from attacks by Hezbollah or other militant jihadists.
|